ISSUE #8

Merchant Ship Collective | The Launch Dock
“Where small businesses learn the truth about power, policy, and opportunities that actually matter.”

Staying Competitive When the System Changes

By now, we’ve uncovered how Public–Private Partnerships reshape markets, influence government decisions, and silently disadvantage small businesses. But understanding the problem is only half the battle. The other half — the part most entrepreneurs never receive — is knowing how to respond.

You cannot stop every PPP.
You cannot prevent every consolidation.
But you can build a strategy that keeps your business visible, competitive, and protected when the landscape starts to shift.

This issue of The Launch Dock lays out the Small Business PPP Defense Strategy — a practical roadmap for navigating a system where public power and private influence are deeply intertwined. It’s not about fear. It’s about positioning. About awareness. About using knowledge as leverage.

And most importantly, it’s about never letting another market change catch you off guard.

The First Principle: Visibility Is Leverage

The biggest disadvantage small businesses face in a PPP-heavy environment is not capability — it’s invisibility.
When decisions move behind closed doors or into private systems, the only counterbalance is public presence.

Small businesses must become active participants in their local ecosystem. That means showing up at city council sessions, tracking school board agendas, monitoring procurement calendars, and being part of the conversations where early decisions are made. Agencies notice who participates. They notice who stays informed. And they remember who stays silent.

Visibility alone won’t stop a partnership — but it prevents the quiet, uncontested shifts that erase local vendors without anyone realizing what happened.

The Second Principle: Understand the System Before You Need It

Too often, entrepreneurs learn about procurement, contracting, and government systems only when they want a contract. By then, they’re years behind. In a world shaped by PPPs, where private vendors influence the requirements and platforms used to issue bids, businesses must learn the system before the opportunity is on the table.

This means getting familiar with how your city or district purchases services, what systems they use, who the current vendors are, and how frequently contracts renew. Most PPPs maintain long-term agreements with predictable renewal cycles. Knowing when those cycles end is a powerful strategic advantage.

Preparation is no longer optional. It is a business asset.

The Third Principle: Build Capacity Before the Market Shifts

One of the ways PPPs edge out small businesses is through abrupt requirement changes — higher insurance minimums, new technology standards, or compliance documentation that only large corporations can meet.

Small businesses cannot wait until the requirements change to figure out how to meet them. Building capacity in advance — whether through partnerships, certifications, training, or strategic hiring — ensures you’re not eliminated before the race even begins.

A business that is prepared can adapt.
A business that is reactive becomes a casualty.

The Fourth Principle: Collective Power Is Stronger Than Individual Advocacy

PPP influence is too large for one business to fight alone. But when a group of local vendors organizes around transparency, open bidding, and fair access, they can become a meaningful counterweight. Coalitions have the power to ask bigger questions, demand clearer processes, and push back against exclusionary systems in ways a single entrepreneur cannot.

Local chambers of commerce, business alliances, neighborhood coalitions, and industry groups can all become platforms for collective advocacy. When multiple businesses show up with the same questions, agencies respond differently. They must.

In a PPP-driven market, collaboration is not competition — it’s strategy.

The Fifth Principle: Ask the Questions Other People Don’t Ask

Government meetings, procurement workshops, and public comment sessions often move quickly because the people in the room don’t know what to ask. Small businesses that learn the right questions can shift the direction of an entire discussion.

Questions like:

• Who will own this new system?

• What happens to public access if a private vendor is managing it?

• How will small businesses integrate with this technology?

• Will future RFPs be written to allow local participation?

• Is this contract being bundled in a way that prevents small vendors from bidding?

These questions expose assumptions. They slow down automatic decisions. They force transparency.
And they remind agencies that the public is paying attention.

The Sixth Principle: Document Everything

Whenever PPP influence grows, documentation becomes your lifeline. Keep copies of bid rejections, email communications, meeting minutes, statements from officials, and public reports. These documents create a paper trail that can be used to challenge decisions, request transparency, or demonstrate inequity.

Documentation is not confrontation — it’s protection.

The Seventh Principle: Use Your Story as Advocacy

Local officials are used to hearing from corporations.
They are not used to hearing from small business owners who can articulate the human impact of losing access to opportunities.

When a small business owner explains how a consolidation threatens their employees, their family, or their community, it reframes the conversation. PPP discussions often revolve around numbers — efficiency, speed, cost. What’s missing is the human reality behind those numbers.

Your story is part of your strategy.
It is your most underestimated tool.

The PPP Defense Strategy in One Sentence

Small businesses survive PPP-driven markets not by fighting the system, but by learning to see it sooner, understand it deeper, and respond to it faster than anyone expects.

This is not about resistance — it’s about readiness.

Call to Action

In the next issue of The Launch Dock, we shift into a deeper level of strategy:
How small businesses can regain market space even in sectors already dominated by PPPs.
Because knowing what’s coming is the first step.
Knowing how to reclaim ground is the next.

In solidarity,

Lyndsay LaBrier
The Merchant Ship Collective

References

Government Accountability Office. (2021). COVID-19: Emergency contracting and the need for transparency. https://www.gao.gov

United States Department of Health & Human Services. (2022). Public health data infrastructure modernization update. https://www.hhs.gov

Wall Street Isn’t Warning You, But This Chart Might

Vanguard just projected public markets may return only 5% annually over the next decade. In a 2024 report, Goldman Sachs forecasted the S&P 500 may return just 3% annually for the same time frame—stats that put current valuations in the 7th percentile of history.

Translation? The gains we’ve seen over the past few years might not continue for quite a while.

Meanwhile, another asset class—almost entirely uncorrelated to the S&P 500 historically—has overall outpaced it for decades (1995-2024), according to Masterworks data.

Masterworks lets everyday investors invest in shares of multimillion-dollar artworks by legends like Banksy, Basquiat, and Picasso.

And they’re not just buying. They’re exiting—with net annualized returns like 17.6%, 17.8%, and 21.5% among their 23 sales.*

Wall Street won’t talk about this. But the wealthy already are. Shares in new offerings can sell quickly but…

👉 My subscribers skip the waitlist

_{*Past performance is not indicative of future returns. Important Reg A disclosures: masterworks.com/cd.}